Simultaneous measurement of net nitrogen mineralization and denitrification rates in soil using nitrification inhibitor 3,5-dimethylpyrazole

Citation

Zebarth, B.J., Burton, D.L., Spence, J., Khosa, M.K. (2020). Simultaneous measurement of net nitrogen mineralization and denitrification rates in soil using nitrification inhibitor 3,5-dimethylpyrazole. Canadian Journal of Soil Science, [online] 100(1), 1-10. http://dx.doi.org/10.1139/cjss-2019-0050

Plain language summary

It is important to be able to quantify the different pathways in the soil nitrogen cycle to be able to understand the environmental performance of agricultural management practices. Two of the most important processes are soil nitrogen mineralization (the conversion of nitrogen from organic to plant available mineral form) and denitrification (the loss of mineral nitrogen to the atmosphere as a gas). Soil nitrogen mineralization is usually measured by incubating a soil and measuring the increase in mineral nitrogen over time. While this works for low and medium soil water content, it does not work at high soil water content as the mineral nitrogen may be lost from the soil by denitrification. In addition, current methods of measuring soil denitrification rates are quite time consuming and expensive, and are difficult to use for routine analyses. In this study we demonstrate a novel approach that allows both soil nitrogen mineralization and denitrification to be measured using a simple assay. The assay uses a nitrification inhibitor (3,5-dimethylpyrazole or DMP). The inhibitor blocks the mineral nitrogen produced by mineralization from being lost by denitrification so that both processes can be measured simultaneously. The assay provides a practical means to quantify the rates of nitrogen mineralization and denitrification simultaneously over a wide range of soil water contents. The assay can be readily scaled up to routinely test multiple soils in an efficient manner, has limited material costs, and is also relatively simple to perform.

Abstract

A practical means to quantify the response of the rates of net N mineralization and denitrification over a wide range of soil water contents is generally lacking. This study examined the potential to use a nitrification inhibitor (NI) assay system to simultaneously estimate the rates of net N mineralization and denitrification, and applied the NI assay to assess the effect of water content on net N mineralization and denitrification rates in two soils with contrasting soil texture. The compound 3,5-dimethylpyrazole (DMP) applied at a rate of 200 mg kg−1 was found to provide essentially complete inhibition of nitrification over the duration of the soil incubation for two soils with contrasting soil texture (clay loam vs. sandy loam) and over a range of soil water contents (35%, 55%, and 85% water-filled pore space). This allowed net N mineralization to be estimated as the accumulation of soil ammonium (NHþ4 ) and of denitrification as the disappearance of added nitrate (NO−3 ). Addition of DMP resulted in a small increase in soil respiration rate but did not appear to influence the rate of net soil N mineralization. The NI assay provides a practical means to quantify the rates of net N mineralization and denitrification simultaneously over a wide range of soil water contents. The assay can be readily scaled up to routinely test multiple soils in an efficient manner, has limited material costs, and is also relatively simple to perform.

Publication date

2020-01-01