Methane emissions from storage of digestate at a dairy manure biogas facility

Citation

Maldaner, L., Wagner-Riddle, C., VanderZaag, A.C., Gordon, R., Duke, C. (2018). Methane emissions from storage of digestate at a dairy manure biogas facility. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, [online] 258 96-107. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.agrformet.2017.12.184

Plain language summary

A large portion of dairy farms use liquid manure storage systems. Liquid manure can be used to generate biogas which may mitigate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, like methane (CH4). Biogas is a mixture of methane, carbon dioxide (CO2) and small amounts of other gases; it can be captured and used to generate electricity and heat. Biodigesters capture the gases produced that would normally escape into the atmosphere from dairy manure storage. Biodigesters receive manure as an input and produce multiple products: biogas, electricity, heat, and digestate which is the organic material left over from anaerobic digestion. Digestate must be stored in large open storages until it can be applied to fields as fertilizer. During storage, CH4 can be produced, which partially offsets the GHG benefits of biogas; however, the amount of emissions from digestate are poorly understood. The purpose of the study was to quantify year-round CH4 emissions from a digestate storage tank, examine the relationship between emissions and its driving factors, and compare these results to a similar emissions dataset from untreated manure measured during one year before the biodigester became operational. This study took place on a commercial farm in Ontario where a biodigester system became operational in May 2012. A micrometeorological mass balance approach was used to measure CH4 fluxes. Total annual CH4 emissions from digestate were 1.0 kg m−3 y−1, which was 85% lower compared to untreated manure. Average monthly volatile solids (VS) mass in the storage tank were reduced by 32%, volatile solids represent the substances in the digestate that can be transformed into biogas. The annual CH4 emissions scaled by VS were 26 g kg−1 VS y−1 for digestate and 76 g kg−1 VS y−1 for manure, suggesting that VS in the digestate were less suitable for CH4 production (less digestible). It was found that digestate temperature was the main driving factor in CH4 emissions, and was more strongly correlated to emission production at all depths for digestate than untreated manure. This study demonstrated a reduction in facility scale CH4 emissions by co-digesting dairy manure and off-farm materials with a 60-day hydraulic retention time and subsequent solid liquid separation. These data are helpful for determining the environmental benefits of on-farm anaerobic digestion facilities.

Abstract

Conventional manure storages are an important source of methane (CH4), a potent greenhouse gas. Anaerobic digestion is an alternative manure management practice potentially able to provide environmental benefits, including the reduction of CH4 emissions from slurry storage. This study was conducted at a commercial farm in Ontario where a biodigester system became operational in May 2012. The purpose was to quantify year-round CH4 emissions from a digestate storage tank, examine the relationship between emissions and its driving factors, and compare these results to a similar emissions dataset from untreated manure measured during one year before the biodigester became operational. A micrometeorological mass balance approach was used to measure CH4 fluxes. Total annual CH4 emissions from digestate were 1.0 kg m−3 y−1, which was 85% lower compared to untreated manure. Monthly average volatile solids (VS) mass in the storage tank was 73 ± 24 Mg for digestate and 107 ± 30 Mg for manure, representing a 32% VS reduction in the tank, suggesting that lower emissions were not only due to VS mass reduction after biodigestion and solid-liquid separation. The annual CH4 emissions scaled by VS were 26 g kg−1 VS y−1 for digestate and 76 g kg−1 VS y−1 for manure, suggesting that VS in the digestate were less suitable for CH4 production (less digestible). This was also verified when investigating the relationship between fluxes and its driving factors: VS concentration did not correlate with CH4 emissions per volume for digestate (r = 0.37; p = 0.29), but did for untreated manure (r = 0.95; p = 0.002). However, the correlation of temperature with emission was stronger for digestate than manure at all depths with no lag, especially at 2 m depth (r = 0.98, p < 0.001). At the same air temperature, digestate was warmer than manure, owing to the digestate leaving the digester at 38 °C. This study showed that co-digestion of dairy manure and off-farm materials (35% of loading volume) with a 60-day hydraulic retention time and subsequent solid liquid separation significantly reduced facility-scale CH4 emissions from the storage tank.

Publication date

2018-08-15

Author profiles