An experimental application of Hypena opulenta as a biocontrol agent for the invasive vine Vincetoxicum rossicum
Citation
Livingstone, S.W., Smith, S.M., Bourchier, R.S., Ryan, K., Roberto, A., Cadotte, M.W. (2020). An experimental application of Hypena opulenta as a biocontrol agent for the invasive vine Vincetoxicum rossicum. Ecological Solutions and Evidence, [online] 1(2), http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/2688-8319.12022
Plain language summary
Pre-release testing for biological control agents is focused primarily on ensuring the specificity and safety of the potential agents. The impact of the agents is considered prior to release in lab studies however, the ultimate test occurs following a release and under field conditions. Here, we present results on the initial feeding impact of a new biological control agent for dog strangling vine, the moth Hypena opulenta, following its release. We compared the impact in both meadow and forest under-story plots which had high densities of dog-strangling vine. There was highly significant defoilation feeding by the caterpillers under both light conditions. Subsequently there was no effect on total seed pod number in sun or shade plots between insect release and control plots with no insects. There was however an increase in several of the individual seed pod characters (pod mass, length and seed mass and seed count within pods) in the insect shade plots only and no difference in sun plots. This was surprising but there are several factors with this study that need further investigation. The release was done late in season, (August) after seed pods may have been set on all plants which may have limited the potential impacts on seed production. The release and establishment of biocontrol agents is a long term process and additional research is ongoing to examine the impact of the biocontrol agents over multiple seasons.
Abstract
1. Pre-release testing for biological control agents is focused primarily on assessment of host-range specificity and safety of potential agents. Agent impact is considered pre-release; however, the ultimate assessment of an agent must occur following release in the field under the target population levels and conditions of the invaded ecosystems. The invasive Eurasian vine, Vincetoxicum rossicum, has spread aggressively through its invaded range of eastern North America since its initial introduction in the late 1800s. In laboratory tests, the Eurasian moth Hypena opulenta has shown great promise as a potential control agent for V. rossicum. 2. We were interested in the defoliating ability of H. opulenta and its subsequent effect on the seed production of V. rossicum under field conditions. To examine this, we established a field site near Kirkfield, Ontario, that consisted of meadow and forest understory plots, both of which were highly invaded by V. rossicum. 3. We report highly significant feeding by H. opulenta in both light conditions. Unexpectedly, we observed a significant increase in seed production following folivory in shade conditions. We observed no significant effect of larval folivory on seed production under sun conditions, where V. rossicum seed production is greater by a factor of 10 as compared to shade conditions. 4. It is unclear how continuous exposure to folivory by H. opulenta will affect mature V. rossicum stands, although it might be expected that such populations would invest in defenses to herbivory, possibly at the expense of reproductive output. In order to better understand if V. rossicum populations in either light condition could exhibit longer-term compensatory growth in response to folivory, further experimental work is needed that examines inter-annual variability in V. rossicum reproduction at variable H. opulenta densities.