Climate change, agricultural inputs, cropping diversity, and environment affect soil carbon and respiration: A case study in Saskatchewan, Canada

Citation

Lychuk, T.E., Moulin, A.P., Lemke, R.L., Izaurralde, R.C., Johnson, E.N., Olfert, O.O., Brandt, S.A. (2019). Climate change, agricultural inputs, cropping diversity, and environment affect soil carbon and respiration: A case study in Saskatchewan, Canada, 337 664-678. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2018.10.010

Plain language summary

The relative impact of climate change, management, diversity, and environment on soil carbon, and soil C decomposed through microbial respiration has seldom been assessed in the scientific literature. Experimental results for the effects of agricultural inputs and cropping diversity on crop sustainability and environmental quality were assessed with the Environmental Policy Integrated Climate model and climate change scenarios. Three levels of agricultural inputs [organic, reduced, and high] and sub-plots comprised of three levels of cropping diversity [low, diversified annual grains, and diversified annual perennial] were used in this study. This modeling study assessed soil organic carbon content, mass of soil C lost through microbial respiration simulated with the model for historical weather (1971-2000) and future climate scenarios (2041-2070). Under climate change, SOC decreased by 1.3% (from 132.3 to 130.6 Mg ha-1) of original stocks in the 0-90 cm. Microbial respiration was affected by climate change and increased by 17% (from 1.92 to 2.25 Mg C ha-1 y-1) due to an increase in annual maximum and minimum temperatures. Input and diversity also affected future SOC and MR. Annual precipitation did not affect SOC and MR, though precipitation in May and June temperatures were important factors. The optimum management for climate change was reduced x diverse annual grains in order to manage SOC and reduce the amount of soil C respired under climate change relative to organic and conventional systems.

Abstract

© 2018 Climate change, agricultural inputs, cropping diversity, and environment have seldom been combined in analyses of soil organic carbon (SOC), and soil C respired through microbial respiration (MR). This modeling study assessed SOC and MR simulated with the Environmental Policy Integrated Climate (EPIC) model for historical weather (1971–2000) and future climate scenarios (2041–2070) for the Alternative Cropping Systems (ACS) study research site in Saskatchewan, Canada. Nineteen years of field and crop management information from the 1994–2013 ACS study were used to validate and provide parameters to the EPIC model for analyses of climate change scenarios. The ACS study consisted of three levels of agricultural inputs [organic (ORG), reduced (RED), and high (HI)] and three levels of cropping diversity [low (LOW), diversified annual grains (DAG), and diversified annuals and perennials (DAP)]. Changes in future SOC and MR under climate change were explored with ANOVA and recursive partitioning in multivariate analyses of inputs, diversity, growing season precipitation (GSP), growing degree days (GDD), annual average maximum, minimum temperatures, cumulative annual precipitation, and terrain attributes (TA). Under climate change, SOC decreased by 1.3% (from 132.3 to 130.6 Mg ha−1) of original stocks in the 0–90 cm. Microbial respiration was affected by climate change and increased by 17% (from 1.92 to 2.25 Mg C ha−1 y−1) due to an increase in annual maximum and minimum temperatures. The increase in annual maximum and minimum temperature was correlated with 32 and 42% of variation in SOC respectively. Monthly growing season GDD was correlated with 14% of variation of SOC in an analysis independent of annual data. Annual precipitation did not affect SOC, though May GSP accounted for 16% of total variation in SOC, while June temperature accounted for 9% of variation in MR. The combination of input and diversity was correlated with 3 and 7% of variation in SOC and MR, respectively. The combination of RED inputs and DAG diversity are the best option to manage SOC and reduce the amount of soil C respired under climate change relative to organic and conventional systems.

Publication date

2019-03-01

Author profiles